Calvinism Offers No Assurance of Salvation
While most Calvinists would say they know they are saved—because “the Spirit bears witness with our spirit that we are children of God” (Rom. 8:16)—assurance of salvation is logically impossible under Calvinism.
Total Depravity = Total Uncertainty
Calvinists believe they were born totally depraved, unable to understand spiritual truth. So how can they possibly know their spirit is bearing accurate witness of their current state of salvation? In other words, how can they know their “feeling of being saved” is anything other than the total depravity they were born with deceiving them?
Evanescent Grace
And it gets even worse. Because of all the passages about falling away (John 15:6, Matt. 18:22-35, Rom. 11:22, 1 Cor. 9:27, 2 Pet. 2:18-22, etc.), John Calvin believed in a doctrine called evanescent grace, which essentially means God sometimes tricks people into thinking they are saved, when in reality they are not—in order to punish them more.
“Experience shows that the reprobate are sometimes affected in a way so similar to the elect that even in their own judgment there is no difference between them…Not that they truly perceive the power of spiritual grace and the sure light of faith; but the Lord, to better convict them, and leave them without excuse, instills into their minds such a sense of goodness as can be felt without the Spirit of adoption…There is a great resemblance and affinity between the elect of God and those who are impressed for a time with a fading faith” (John Calvin, Institutes, 3.2.11).
How could one ever have assurance of salvation with such a doctrine?
Biblical Assurity
Thankfully, nothing in the Bible suggests God deceives people about their salvation—just the opposite! As stated above, “the Spirit bears witness with our spirit that we are children of God” (Rom. 8:16). And because we were made God’s image—not totally depraved, unable to understand spiritual truth—we can trust this witness.
Other evidences of salvation include obeying Jesus’ commands (John 14:15) and loving other Christians (1 John 3:14). And thankfully, we don’t have to worry about God tricking us into thinking we are doing these things when in fact we are not.
Common Calvinist Objection
Calvinists claim non-Calvinists don’t have assurance of salvation because non-Calvinists believe they can fall away—which leads to uncertainty.
Response: Many non-Calvinists believe in “once saved, always saved,” which essentially means that while disobedient Christians can lose blessings and rewards, they can never lose their salvation. So the Calvinist objection wouldn’t apply to this group.
As to those like myself who do believe Christians can fall away (because of the many passages that say that—see above)…Even I believe in the eternal security of the believer. It’s just that one must be a believer to be secure. A believer is someone who trusts God enough to do what he says and confesses his sins after falling short. Such a person never has to worry about losing his salvation!
Now if someone foolishly decides to walk away from God, then it’s true he won’t be saved because unbelievers stand condemned (John 3:18, 36). But knowing this fact doesn’t give me uncertainty in the least because I don’t plan on walking away! And no outside force can make me walk away either (Rom. 8:38-39, John 10:28). So my salvation is secure.
So the Calvinist objection fails with this group too.
By Alex Polyak, Answering Calvinism, 10/29/26